Rating of car alarms. Rating of car alarms with feedback and autostart Review of alarms with autostart

By 2016, more and more car alarms are becoming telematic, moving away from traditional display and control using a key fob with an LCD display. The exception is cars that are not equipped with a standard radio channel to control the central locking, as well as cars operating in regions that do not have a comfortable GSM network coverage area. The evolution is carried out not only thanks to technology, but also due to the transition of these systems to the mid-range and budget segments.

Taking into account the growing trend in the share of modern car alarms produced and in accordance with the concept of the evolution of car alarms, we chose telematics systems with tag authorization for the test.

Tested systems:

You can briefly see the testing of some consumer properties in this video:

The systems were evaluated according to a number of criteria; for ease of understanding, we divided them into 4 blocks:

• Safety
• Comfort
• Technologies

Safety

It should be noted that all systems use dialog code and individual encryption keys. Encryption keys in all systems are stated to be at least 128 bits.

Lately, code grabbers with retransmission have been increasingly used for car thefts. A modern system is able to protect against it by blocking the standard radio channel; all systems except the Ghost have this property, partly due to the initialization algorithm, partly due to the tag’s energy resource.

Below is a table comparing the different parameters. We did not describe the matching functions (encoding, authorization factor, etc.) so as not to distract the reader from the comparison. The assessment method is simple - according to the traffic light type: red = 0 points (not implemented or implemented to a small extent), yellow = 1 point (implemented to an average extent), green = 2 points (implemented to the fullest extent).

Comparison of security according to different parameters:

Comfort

When comparing comfort functions, we focused on measuring the current consumption of tags and the main alarm unit. This was done to determine the estimated battery life under various operating conditions.

Tag consumption:

Agent MS PRO:

This system has the smallest battery capacity (CR2016) - only 0.075 Ah, which also determines the smallest size of the tag body among competitors. The issue of energy resources is very important here, and Magic Systems engineers managed to optimize consumption indicators. At rest, the tag emits once every two seconds, when the connection is lost, it goes into fast polling mode with radiation once per second, after 30 seconds it returns to its original state. Only one packet is sent for a request, but as practice shows, the recognition radio channel works quite stably. The estimated battery life was 384 days.

AutoLis Mobile:

This system uses the most capacious CR2430 battery. 2 packets are broadcast, after which the broadcast is listened to. Despite the fact that the system uses an old transceiver, the results are very positive. The estimated service life of the battery under average operating conditions is 611 days.

Excellent Revo5:

The largest and longest-lived tag. The main unit always starts the dialogue, so the tag sleeps all the time and periodically listens to the air, in security mode once every 1.2 seconds. This is the secret of longevity, despite the fact that the battery used is an average CR2032 (220 mAh). In average use mode, the battery in the tag should last 1122 days (more than 3 years).

Pandect 1700:

Representatives of the manufacturer Pandora announced a change in the algorithm of the radio channel, because There have been many complaints about the tag's battery draining quickly. This is clearly visible on the graph; compared to the previous test, we see a reduction in the number of messages sent on the air: previously there were 4, now there are 2. However, the tag remains with the shortest battery life compared to its competitors. The radiation period is once per second with a fairly high current consumption. Near the system, the tag consumes almost 2.5 times less than far from it. When the tag is at home, the average current consumption is 30 μA, this is a fairly high figure that clearly needs optimization. In average operating conditions, the tag will last 240 days.

Ghost 840:

The tag has an algorithm for exchanging data with the base unit in the same way as in Excellent. The block starts the dialogue first, the tag is in broadcast listening mode with a period of 1 second. After successful identification, data exchange between the tag and the base module no longer occurs. This significantly reduces energy costs. However, the dialogue is undergoing a rather consuming process (see graph); this may probably be the reason for the inability to enable the blocking logic of the standard radio channel. In average operating mode, the tag will last 441 days.

StarLine M96:

Unlike other tags, Starline’s had to be tested under conditions where the accelerometer was activated (i.e. in motion), so the measurements were not 3, like for each tag, but 6.

In Starline, the Bluetooth transmission protocol is clearly visible, this can be seen from 3 request packets on the air. After each packet is transmitted, the broadcast is listened to. The M96 system uses algorithms for generating temporary keys with a timestamp, and data exchange is more complex than that of competing systems. The conditions listed above cause increased energy consumption. The engineers tried to compensate for this by interacting with the accelerometer built into the tag; this tag is the only one tested that uses an accelerometer to save energy. In average use mode, the battery in the tag should last 362 days. An interesting observation: the type of transceiver used in the Starline tag changed; this was done to implement support for the Bluetooth 4.0 algorithm, incl. to support as an element of smartphone authorization.

Comparison of comfort functions according to different parameters:

Technologies

Software and hardware adaptability

It is worth noting this criterion as the most interesting for advanced installers. In the work of an installer, various needs constantly arise to adapt the installed alarm system to a particular task. To evaluate this point, we use a set of capabilities of the systems under test, such as: circuitry and technical capabilities, reassignment of inputs, outputs, polarities, energy saving management, event management via digital buses, the ability to use system event sources from the car’s digital buses for programming, situational logic and generation of system events according to specified algorithms. The listed properties are indicated briefly and are not fully disclosed; the assessment of the adaptive capabilities of alarms is formed using the author's algorithm. According to our estimates, the best software and hardware adaptability systems are found in StarLine, Excellent, then AutoLis and Pandect, followed by Agent and Prizrak. The scores are shown in the comparison table.

Car alarm consumption

This test is very important to determine the average battery life under various operating conditions. In order to fully check all possible conditions, we make calculations according to the summer and winter seasons, taking into account the dependence of the battery capacity on the temperature coefficient.

We also measure the voltage drop across the resistor through which our alarms are connected to the car’s standard battery, under normal conditions and under conditions of strong interference. We create strong interference to the GSM network using a GSM broadcast suppressor (jammer). All systems were connected to the Skoda Octavia car. We waited for the car's electronics to go into sleep mode and began measuring the consumption of the systems under test. We consider the capacity of the standard battery to be 60Ah. In our calculations, we will take the consumption of the standard system as 15mA. The conditions for guaranteed engine starting are 30% of the nominal battery capacity. We will not give examples of summer operation calculations in advance, because... at a temperature of 20 degrees, under the above conditions and current consumption of the tested systems, the battery will last from 33 to 45 days, which is an acceptable norm. Therefore, we will evaluate the extreme points where the situation can turn out most painfully for the user - this is winter + conditions of strong GSM interference.

Agent MS PRO:

In terms of current consumption, the figure is overestimated compared to competitors; in winter, with such consumption, in conditions of strong GSM network interference, the battery will last 12 days. During testing, microimmobilizers 100,200,300 were not connected, but their consumption currents will not greatly affect the result.

AutoLis Mobile:

Avtolis Mobile was tested with a GPS antenna, without a CAN module. It can be seen that in security mode the average current consumption was 27.7 mA, and in conditions of strong interference it was 55.7 mA. When calculated based on initial conditions, taking into account the winter period of operation, at a temperature of -20 degrees, in the absence of GSM communication, the car’s battery will last for 9 days. Returning from a two-week vacation, you may find yourself with nothing, i.e. with a dead battery. This manufacturer came out of this situation in the following way: when a critical voltage threshold of the standard battery is reached, the GSM modem is simply turned off. It turns back on when an alarm occurs. This method is a “patch” in this situation and requires adjustment of the software or hardware platform to optimize consumption. After all, leaving our car in conditions of strong GSM interference (and this is not easy to control), we risk either draining the battery or being left without communication with the car, for example, if we want to remotely start the engine, we will not be able to do this, because GSM modem is turned off. Also, in such conditions, it is not entirely clear whether the car is in the same place, or whether the car thief, who has a jammer, dragged it away on a tow truck long ago.

Excellent Revo5

In winter, if there is no GSM connection, your car with Excellent Revolution 5 installed will no longer be able to start on the 13th day.

Pandect X-1700

Unlike its competitors, Pandect can go into sleep mode in the absence of a GSM network. However, the performance in “normal life” is much worse than that of other tested systems. In “bad” conditions the battery will last for 15 days. You can return from a two-week trip and start the engine. During testing, the GPS module and others not included in the basic kit were not connected.

Ghost 840:

The lowest consumption under normal conditions among competitors, but the most extreme consumption in conditions of suppression of the GSM network is 58.75 mA. If we add 15mA of normal consumption, then in winter conditions and GSM interference or lack of a GSM network, the owner risks not starting the engine after 9 days.

StarLine M96M:

In terms of consumption - the golden mean. In poor conditions, the battery will last for a two-week vacation; under normal conditions, the performance is also excellent.

Comparison of technologies based on different parameters:

Comparison using the full price method

We thought it would be unfair to compare systems in different configurations, so we resorted to a handicap and compiled the resulting table, which included a number of components with their full cost, including installation. Prices are average for the Moscow region; regional pricing policies of manufacturers may adjust these figures downward by up to 30%.

Results

We did not make a general summary assessment for all resulting parameters for alarms; this is due to a number of reasons listed below. This test is designed to help consumers and installers evaluate the properties of modern alarms. The resulting assessments are an indirect indicator for making decisions on the choice of systems and depend on the specific tasks pursued by the user, as well as the capabilities of the vehicle. For example, the pandect has a miniature size and is interesting as an element of hidden installation in non-standard places in the car, but it has limited analog connection capabilities and is more suitable for modern German cars; The Excellent system, despite its high cost compared to competing products, is a tool with wide technical capabilities, suitable for custom installation; MS Agent combines the golden mean of price and functionality, as well as the main components that are maximally integrated into the main unit, which installers will undoubtedly like. Therefore, before making the final choice of device, we recommend consulting with specialists to develop the most optimal solution for your needs.

Choosing a car alarm is not an easy task, because in this case the integrity of your car depends on it, and it’s no secret that many people have been collecting money for more than one year to buy it. Not so long ago, in order to steal a car, it was enough to have a metal ruler and other simple devices; today, car thieves use modern means that can cope with even a simple alarm system. To prevent this from happening, we offer a rating of car alarms in 2016, among which you can find the most reliable device that guarantees the safety of your car.

Top 5 best car alarms

Manufacturers of car alarms, understanding the responsibility entrusted to them, are constantly improving their range of models, providing them with various functions that increase the efficiency of their work. When buying an alarm, car owners are faced with new concepts, such as auto start, remote engine start, including diesel, on a schedule, and the presence of a GPS interface for two-way communication with the car owner. There are many proven companies among car alarm manufacturers; new manufacturers are also entering the market, often offering equally functional devices. The rating of the best car alarms, according to experts and customer reviews, looks like this:

Perhaps you use another car alarm system, because among their wide variety there are a sufficient number of functional devices that provide adequate protection for your car. In any case, we do not recommend saving on car alarms and succumbing to the temptation to buy a very cheap product from a little-known manufacturer from the Middle Kingdom.

The modern world requires car owners to take increased precautions to protect their cars. Every day new products appear in this area that allow you to feel as confident as possible about your vehicle. The constant development of innovative methods is carried out because the development of technologies for the illegal seizure of a vehicle also does not stand still. It's like a constant battle between those trying to protect the car and those trying to take it illegally. Achievements in the development of car alarms are impressive and to some extent surprising in their modernity and readiness to answer all questions of modern requirements.

To help drivers understand the question of which car alarms with auto start are better, we have compiled a rating of the best car alarms.

In tenth place we have the Prizrak-810 automotive protection system. The system allows you to be in touch with your car at any distance. It is designed in such a way that no key fob is needed. The settings are very easy to change, making it suitable for any conditions.

The Pandect X-2050 vehicle protection system is distinguished by its miniature size, is easy to configure and is capable of providing the highest level of protection. The owner is constantly in touch with his car. It fits all brands of cars, from economy to business class.

A unique development in the field of car protection “Ghost-830” receives eighth place in our rating of the best car alarms. This miracle of the domestic industry will protect your car at the highest level. It differs from its relative, which occupies tenth place, in a more advanced configuration.

The seventh line of the rating goes to the StarLine E90 GSM car alarm. This alarm has built-in anti-interference protection, can automatically start the engine. But its main advantage is the guarantee of high vehicle protection. Fits any car and has a compact size.

The smallest, but this does not mean that the simplest car alarm “Pandect X-2010” ranks sixth in the most authoritative car protection systems. The kit includes a keychain with a liquid crystal display. The alarm maintains a high level of security and is constantly in touch with the owner.

The top five is opened by Pandect X-1170. This security system does not require a key fob, as it can be controlled from any distance via a mobile phone. The system allows you to monitor certain vehicle functions and devices.

We placed the Pandora dxl-3910 car alarm in fourth place in the ranking. The alarm system provides more than fifteen independent protection zones, is easily installed in any car model and provides absolute protection for your vehicle. It can become part of the car's electronic system, which significantly increases the level of safety.

The top three best automatic car alarms are opened by the “Ghost” of the 800 series. The system is characterized by the fact that it does not require any key fobs, but it guarantees the protection of your car from all means of modern theft and allows you to stay in touch with the car at any distance.

The second was “StarLine D94 GSM/GPS”. It has almost all the characteristics of the above-mentioned car alarms and is a unique development. Capable of causing insoluble problems to every car thief. Its advantage is the presence of a very powerful transmitter channel, which brought this system to second place.

There is always an unspoken competition between car alarm manufacturers and burglars. The former invent new methods of defense, while the latter tirelessly learn to overcome them. The simplest security systems these days become an obstacle only for children. But the more complex the alarm system, the higher the price the car owner has to pay. Today on the domestic market you can find both affordable devices and sophisticated security systems. How to choose the most suitable option for your car?

1. Single-sided models recently dominated sales, and were also included in all TOP and ratings. But today the lack of feedback is becoming the main disadvantage. And the sound produced in a large city can be heard at a distance of up to 100 m.
2. Two-way car alarms look much more attractive from a reliability point of view. If there is unauthorized entry into the car interior, the car not only emits a sound signal, but also activates an alarm on the owner’s key fob. Some modern models allow you to assess the degree of threat by looking at the key fob display. The range of such systems reaches 3-4 km in a metropolitan area.
3. Alarms with GSM and GPS modules are becoming even more advanced. They allow you to communicate with the car via mobile communications or satellites. The rich functionality of some of them allows you to monitor the movement of the car in case of theft.
4. A very useful and convenient feature in modern car alarms is remote engine start. Thanks to this option, you can warm up the car without leaving your cozy apartment or house.

Our review includes the best car alarms. When compiling the rating, the following criteria were taken into account:

• efficiency;
• availability;
• expert opinion;
• user reviews.

The best inexpensive alarm system with feedback: budget up to 5,000 rubles

One of the most popular types of car alarms are models with feedback. Their main difference from simple systems is that when trying to break into a car, the owner will see on a special pager (always supplied) what is happening to his vehicle - the corresponding indicator will light up.

4 Centurion X6

Reliable scanning protection
Country Russia
Average price: 3,700 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.4

Feedback in car alarms has one significant vulnerability. Using a simple scanner, attackers intercept the signal sent to the owner's pager and gain full access to all options. Manufacturers are aware of this vulnerability and are constantly improving protection technologies. In particular, this model uses a floating code system.

In simple terms, at the moment of interception, the system automatically changes the access code and blocks it for strangers. The codes change constantly, so the possibility of interception is virtually eliminated. It is worth noting that such technologies are not new, but as experts note, in this car alarm they are implemented to the highest possible quality. Also worth noting is the advantage of range. Here it is 1200 meters. This is a lot for such an inexpensive alarm system, and allows the owner to receive information about his car even when located at a considerable distance from it.

3 Scher-Khan Logicar B

Best price
Country: South Korea
Average price: 4,450 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.4

The top three in the ranking of the best car alarms costing up to 5,000 rubles is closed by the Scher-Khan Logicar B system. This is one of the most popular models of the Korean brand. The price of the system is slightly lower than that of competitors, while the signaling range is 1.5 km. The complex is adaptable to cars with both manual and automatic transmissions. The proprietary MAGIC CODE PRO radio signal encryption algorithm will protect against scanning, interception and intelligent hacking.

One of the advantages of this complex is the ability to remotely and automatically (for example, by time) start the engine, which will be especially convenient when operating the car in winter. To control the system, a special key fob is used, which has all the necessary indicators, including the feedback level and the presence of a signal. The complex operates silently, without attracting unnecessary attention. The key fob is powered by a standard AAA battery.

2 DaVINCI PHI-370

Budget model with an informative display
Country: China
Average price: 2,700 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.5

Closed loop alarms don't have to be expensive. There are also budget models that work no worse than top market leaders such as Starline. The main advantage here is the price. This is one of the most inexpensive models on the modern market. At the same time, as experts note, in terms of quality and reliability it is not much inferior to its competitors. In addition, there is a very informative display that shows everything you need. Sensors work on seven sides of the car, and the exact location of the impact location is displayed on the key fob.

As for the shortcomings, the acoustic shock sensor should be noted. It is located in the alarm housing itself, and reacts to changes in the acoustic background at a given distance. What does this mean for the car owner? First of all, the possibility of frequent false positives. If you set the sensor too sensitively, it will react to even small noises. And by reducing sensitivity, you risk missing the moment of actually breaking the lock.

When choosing a car alarm, you should pay attention to the following parameters:

• Radio protocol type. The most secure is the interactive one (installed in most systems), since during its operation, data is exchanged between the module and the pager over an encrypted channel.
• Availability of a secure data transmission channel. This function will protect car owners from “intelligent” hacking.
• Availability of GSM module. Allows the system to operate at any distance between the owner and the car, and effectively manage a large number of parameters.
• System operating range. It ranges from 1200 to 2000 meters and determines the distance at which control can be carried out using a pager.
• Informative keychain. It is worth taking a closer look at the models whose pager displays a large number of different parameters. This means that the system controls everything that happens to the car.
• Remote engine start. The function allows you to start the power unit using a pager or mobile phone.
• Number of security zones. The more of them, the more reliably the car is protected from third-party influences.

1 Alligator C-200

Dynamic code security system
Country: Taiwan (China)
Average price: 4,500 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.6

The leader in the rating of the best inexpensive alarm systems with feedback is the Alligator C-200 model. This is one of the most reliable budget models from the Taiwanese manufacturer. All data is transmitted via a communication channel protected by KeeloqTM dynamic code. This guarantees high system reliability and protection against interception. If an attempt is made to steal the car, the Anti-HiJack mode will block the engine from starting. In security mode, the alarm is absolutely silent and has protection against false alarms, which will allow the owner not to be alarmed without reason.

The security system includes a keychain with a Russified menu. Control is carried out using 4 mechanical keys, each of which is responsible for its own separate action. If the alarm is triggered, the key fob will notify the owner with a sound signal, and the part of the car that has been tampered with will flash on the LCD display - the doors, hood or trunk. In alert mode, the communication range is about 1200 meters.

The best inexpensive alarm system with auto start

Autostart is a convenient feature that allows you to start the engine remotely. It is enough to press a button on the pager (and in some models simply set a timer), and the car will start on its own. This option will certainly be appreciated by car owners who actively use their car in winter.

4 TOMAHAWK 9.7

Maximum range of options at an attractive price
Country: Taiwan
Average price: 5,070 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.5

The Taiwanese company Tomahawk produces a wide range of car alarms. Their main difference from competitors is their affordable price. In essence, this is a budget model, but with a maximum range of functions. Not only feedback is implemented here, but also the ability to control the engine remotely. In addition to the standard autostart of the car engine, there is a timer that allows you to set the autostart for certain periods of time. A very convenient and necessary function, especially in the realities of the Russian winter.

The system also has protection against false alarms. Before giving the owner an alarm signal, the automation first processes it and looks for the root cause. If one is not found, the signal is regarded as false and is not sent to the pager. Separately, it is necessary to say about the range of action, which here is 1300 meters, and this is the best indicator in the budget segment. With such an alarm you do not have to park your car close to your house. The radius is quite enough even to leave the car in the nearest parking lot.

3 CENMAX Vigilant ST-7

Best price
Country: Taiwan (China)
Average price: 4,400 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.5

The third place in the ranking of the best car alarms with auto start is occupied by the functional CENMAX Vigilant ST-7 system. This is the most attractive option in terms of price - cheaper than competitors in the TOP 3, the range of features will please even picky car owners. All sensors can be adjusted for sensitivity and, importantly, have small dimensions. A small LCD display displays all system parameters - from communication level and battery charge to the integrity of a particular element of the car.

Automatic engine start is capable of starting the car at temperatures down to -40 degrees, which is especially important for Russian frosts. Proper setup of the system completely eliminates false alarms and allows you to reliably protect your car from hacking. Buyers highlight the relatively low cost, ease of operation and informative key fob as the advantages of the system. Weaknesses include the lack of a cover for the key fob and difficulties with installation.

2 StarLine A63 ECO

3D vehicle integrity sensor
Country Russia
Average price: 5,600 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.6

The domestic StarLine A63 ECO system is in second place in the ranking of the best car alarms with auto start. A compact and effective complex – that’s what can be said about this car alarm. The kit, in addition to the main module, transmitting device and pager keychain, includes all the wires necessary for connection. A special 3D sensor, which is mounted together with the system, monitors the integrity of the car body and its position in space, and if there are any suspicious deviations, it will immediately notify the owner.

A distinctive feature of the system is the automatic arming of the car, which will be especially relevant for inattentive motorists. The channel through which all data is transmitted is encrypted, which ensures high reliability of the entire system. The automatic engine start that the system is equipped with starts the car in any frost without any problems. Another important feature of this car alarm is the extended warranty period of 36 months.

1 KGB GX-5RS

Best two-channel protection
Country: China
Average price: 5,900 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.9

Only an alarm installation specialist can evaluate all the advantages of two-channel protection. In simple terms, the system first sends a signal to the owner through the most open channel, and if it is not intercepted and there is no interference on it, a second signal is sent, this time through a closed channel, and only after that you get the ability to control. Of course, all this sounds too primitive, but in general terms the technology is clear.

In this model, the two-stage protection system is implemented at its best. This is noted by both the specialists who conducted the tests and the owners of cars on which this model is installed. You will also be pleased with the keychain, or rather its information content. There are a lot of useful icons that display everything that happens to your car. Protection against false alarms allows you to immediately determine whether the car was actually hit or whether the cat jumped onto the roof. The range, however, is not so large, only 900 meters. At this distance, you can autostart and activate the protection system.

The best alarm system with auto start: price - quality

Below are the best car alarms with a convenient auto-start function with the best price-quality ratio.

4 ZONT ZTC-700S

The best combination of price and quality
Country: China
Average price: 9,900 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.4

This alarm system cannot be called budget, but if you carefully study the functionality and technical characteristics, it becomes clear that the price is quite justified. Let's start with the fact that we have a model with feedback and autostart, working both via a standard encryption channel and GSM technology.

The owner can control his car using any smartphone, regardless of the installed operating system. The menu has a lot of convenient functions. Even autostart is implemented at the highest level. It can be adjusted both by time, and this will surprise no one, and by temperature outside. The most convenient option that allows you to always keep the engine warm and save fuel if the outside temperature is not low enough. The system also stores the entire history of the vehicle’s movements: mileage, number of engine starts and stops, route and other data. You can view the history in a special application, and carry out the necessary analysis there.

3 Scher-Khan LOGICAR 6i

Operation in the temperature range from -85 °C to +50 °C
Country: South Korea
Average price: 10,490 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.5

The functional system Scher-Khan LOGICAR 6i closes the top three best alarm systems with automatic engine start in terms of price and quality ratio. Signal encoding is carried out according to the proprietary MAGIC CODE PRO 3 standard, which has been tested on many Sherkhan car alarms and has shown excellent results. If necessary, you can set a two-digit access code to the salon, which is known only to the owner and is entered from the key fob. The system easily copes with its functions even at extreme temperatures from -85 °C to +50 °C.

The engine can be started remotely by pressing a button on the pager or automatically (the start time or minimum temperature value is set). The system is perfectly adapted to work on cars with both automatic and manual transmission. The communication range between the pager and the unit reaches 1500 m, which is convenient if you often leave your vehicle in parking lots. The key fob displays such important information as signal level, battery charge and temperature inside the car.

2 Pandora DXL 3210i

Security of 12 car zones
Country Russia
Average price: RUB 13,544.
Rating (2019): 4.7

The second place in the ranking of the best alarm systems with auto-start function is occupied by Pandora DXL 3210i. This is one of the most reliable systems on the market (this is why it is so expensive). The complex protects 12 zones outside and inside the vehicle, including not only the doors, hood and trunk, but also such parameters as pressing the brake pedal and monitoring the motion sensor. A special SLAVE mode allows you to transfer control of the system from the Pandora key fob to the standard car key.

To facilitate the alarm installation process, the kit includes all the necessary wires and ties, and you can perform the complex firmware yourself via a USB port. Sensors operating in the system are configured individually. The alarm is controlled via a key fob with an LCD display, which displays all the current information about the condition of the car. It has an optimized user menu in Russian and a sealed case.

1 Sheriff ZX-1090

High quality at an attractive price
A country: USA (made in China)
Average price: 4,590 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.8

Here we have a budget car alarm, which we couldn’t miss from our top list. We’ll talk about the technical aspects below, but I’d like to start with reviews, of which there are a lot on the Internet. One gets the impression that this is the best model on the market, at least for the money. First of all, buyers who decide to install this model praise it for its reliability and durability.

Now regarding the characteristics. The alarm system operates using a two-channel encryption system and dynamic code change. It is almost impossible to hack it using a simple interception method. Sensors are installed on three sides, and this can be called a disadvantage if we ignore the initial cost of the system. Disadvantages also include a relatively small coverage radius. Here it is only 700 meters. On the one hand, this is quite enough, but many leading brands, such as Starline, have long ago almost doubled this value.

The best alarm system with GSM

Alarms with GSM are the most advanced type of security systems for a car. In addition to the many functions contained in the head microcontroller, it constantly maintains communication with the owner via a GSM signal. Notifications about actions with the car come in the form of SMS messages or calls. In addition, you can easily track where the car is at any time.

4 PRIZRAK 8GL

Best model with memory function
Country Russia
Average price: 21,600 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.4

Not every car owner is ready to install an alarm system for that kind of money, but it made it into our top list due to its characteristics, and the cost can be considered a disadvantage, but in fairness, we note that a system with such a set of options simply cannot be cheap. So, we have before us a Russian-made product that is ahead of many of its competitors, both in terms of basic functionality and the availability of additional options.

The system is telematic, that is, it has the ability to connect via a GSM module. But unlike most models, it uses a three-way connection. That is, if the mobile signal fails or your smartphone is turned off, you will continue to control your car, but using a standard radio signal sent to the pager. The alarm system works with Glonass technology and allows you to constantly monitor the location of your car, and the developers call the best energy saving system the main achievement.

3 Alligator SP-75RS

The most affordable car alarm with GSM
Country: Taiwan
Average price: 4,890 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.5

The Alligator SP-75RS car alarm has a large number of protective functions at an affordable price. Using a double dialogue code helps prevent electronic hacking. The system has protection against radio interference, as well as a fast response to the signal. The alarm system is versatile in application; it can be installed on cars with gasoline or diesel engines, with manual or automatic transmission. The device provides remote engine start (with the necessary delay) from a distance of up to 600 m.

Motorists in reviews speak flatteringly about the availability of many functions and the affordable price of the Alligator SP-75RS car alarm. Double dialogue provides reliable protection against electronic hacking. The disadvantages are the rapid discharge of batteries and the limited range of the key fob.

2 StarLine Twage B94 GSM Slave

The optimum ratio of price and quality
Country Russia
Average price: 23,500 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.6

The popular alarm system with the GSM module StarLine Twage B94 GSM Slave takes second place in the ranking of the best security systems for a car. This is an excellent model with good functionality for little money. The built-in 3D sensor accurately determines the position of the car in space and, at the slightest deviation from the norm, will immediately notify the owner about this via a notification to a mobile phone or key fob pager. With intelligent auto start, you can start the engine at a specified time.

The communication range between the unit and the StarLine pager is about 2 km, and then the GSM module is responsible for monitoring the vehicle parameters, capable of reporting the exact coordinates of the vehicle at any time. Two stages of signal protection guarantee high system resistance to attempts to read the code. If an attempt is made to steal, the engine will be blocked from starting and all electronic controls of the vehicle will be blocked. The complex is capable of controlling all vehicle systems: from climate control to lighting.

1 Pandora DXL 5000 S

The best protection system for a car
Country Russia
Average price: 43,221 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.8

Pandora DXL 5000 S is rightfully considered the best alarm system with a GSM module. This is a full-fledged security complex with many functions and excellent potential. Of course, the system costs a lot of money, but it is the best option to protect your car from theft. In addition to sophisticated signal transmission with monitoring of the stability of data exchange (protection from “jammers”), the complex is equipped with a GSM module, thanks to which it is possible to control parameters such as temperature and battery voltage.

Pandora is controlled from any device that has Internet access. In a secure personal account, you can change the parameters of the complex, start the engine and control the operation of vehicle systems. In addition, thanks to the GSM module, you can obtain the exact coordinates of the vehicle at any time. For quick operation of the alarm system, a key fob with an informative LCD display is provided. The built-in module keeps statistics of vehicle movements and updates it every month.

The best telematic car alarms

Telematic security systems have become a new type of car alarms. They allow you to control the inaccessibility of your vehicle using your mobile phone.

4 Pandect X-1100

Function of notifying relatives about an accident
Country Russia
Average price: RUB 14,090.
Rating (2019): 4.6

The Pandect X-1100 car alarm does not have the full range of telematic functions. But for some, not all of them are needed. But the option of notifying relatives about an accident involving the owner’s car can be very useful. It is a pity that it is impossible to determine the location of the car on the map. The alarm cannot be controlled via the Internet or mobile application. You can disarm the car using a standard key with a radio signal, or using a mobile phone. Validation occurs using two radio tags, which limits the circle of users to the car. You can connect a GPS receiver or module to the device to automatically start the engine.

In reviews, car enthusiasts point out such advantages of the Pandect X-1100 system as a built-in GSM receiver, wireless communication with a relay unit, and an affordable price. Disadvantages include reduced telematics and the need to purchase additional modules for autostart.

3 StarLine M96L

Autonomous operation, GPS beacons
Country Russia
Average price: 23,500 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.7

The maximum level of vehicle protection against theft is provided by the StarLine M96L alarm system. It has a built-in lithium-ion battery and GPS beacons. Even if the system is disconnected from the on-board network, the car device will remain operational by sending a signal. This allows you to track the location of the car at any time. A distinctive feature of car alarms from older StarLine models is control using a mobile phone. The Bluetooth port is used for communication. The smart filling is capable of sending SMS to the owner, where error codes are indicated. For travel lovers, the ability to connect a second SIM card will not be superfluous.

Car owners who have installed the StarLine M96L alarm system note a number of positive aspects. This is the ability to work autonomously, dual connection with the phone (GPS and Bluetooth). The disadvantages of the system include the lack of support for keyless immobilizer bypass.

2 ZTC-701M Slave

Cheapest telematics model
Country: China
Average price: 6,785 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.8

It is believed that telematic security systems are very expensive, and not everyone can afford them. But here we have a product from a Chinese brand that claims to be the best manufacturer of budget alarms, and that is why it is in our top. So what is there? Let's start with the settings. In reviews of telematics systems, owners who decide to install them often complain about the lack of flexibility of these settings. That is, there are a lot of functions, but understanding them in a mobile application is very difficult. Here this drawback has been eliminated, and the system can be configured from a website on which each owner has a personal account.

As for purely technical aspects, they are average. For example, the radio signal range is only 600 meters. Manufacturers focus specifically on mobile positioning, so they apparently forgot about the standard signal. Three sides of protection. It’s also quite small, considering that Starline’s closest competitor has long surpassed the seven-sensor mark and has no plans to stop.

1 Ghost 840

Full feature set
Country Russia
Average price: 21,500 rub.
Rating (2019): 4.9

The Prizrak 840 car alarm has a full range of functions that are inherent in this category of security systems. The model allows you to control the car using a standard key or a mobile application. As protection, the owner is provided with wearable radio tags or a PIN code is entered using the standard car buttons. The alarm system is equipped with an ultra-compact blocking relay, to which there is no need to pull wires. Therefore, the installer can be installed anywhere in the car. Communication with the central unit is carried out through a power cable, which solves the problem with radio interference. The model allows you to remotely start the engine, bypassing the immobilizer.

Car enthusiasts and experts note such positive qualities of the Prizrak 840 car alarm as rich functionality, reliability, and high resistance to theft. The disadvantages of the system include the high price.